Will I Find a Good or Great Body Shop When Price Shopping?
When it comes to getting your car repaired after an accident, price matters—but it shouldn’t be the only thing that matters. It’s understandable to want the best deal, but shopping strictly by price can come with risks. Not all auto body shops are created equal. While you might find a good shop at a reasonable price, there’s also a chance you could end up with shoddy work that causes headaches (and more expenses) down the road.
The truth is, finding a great body shop requires more than just comparing price tags. Here are some key steps you can take to improve your chances of finding a reputable, trustworthy auto body shop—one that provides high-quality work and peace of mind, not just a low estimate.
1. Ask for Recommendations
One of the most reliable ways to find a quality auto body shop is by word of mouth. Ask your friends, family members, coworkers, and neighbors if they’ve had a positive experience at a local shop. Personal recommendations often point you toward businesses that are professional, honest, and reliable—qualities you can’t always determine just by looking at an estimate.
2. Read Online Reviews
Next, do your research online. Platforms like Google, Yelp, and Angi offer a wealth of customer feedback. Pay close attention to what reviewers say about the quality of the repair work, customer service, communication, and pricing. Patterns in reviews—good or bad—can reveal a lot about what kind of experience you can expect.
3. Check for Credentials and Certifications
Reputable auto body shops will have proper licensing and insurance, which helps protect you as the customer. But don’t stop there—look for shops with certifications from organizations like I-CAR (Inter-Industry Conference on Auto Collision Repair) or ASE (Automotive Service Excellence). These credentials show that the technicians are trained, tested, and held to industry standards.
4. Visit Multiple Shops
Before deciding, visit a few body shops in person. A walk-through gives you a chance to see how the shop operates and ask questions directly. Ask about their repair process, the types of parts they use (OEM vs. aftermarket), how long the repairs will take, and whether they work with your insurance company. Take note of their cleanliness, organization, and customer service. Professionalism matters.
5. Get Multiple Estimates
It’s smart to collect several estimates—not just to find the best price, but to see how different shops approach the job. Some may cut corners to offer a lower bid, while others may include higher-quality parts or more thorough repair work. Comparing estimates gives you insight into what’s really being offered—and what might be missing.
6. Inquire About Warranties
A great shop will stand behind their work. Ask if they offer a warranty on parts and labor. A lifetime warranty is a good sign that the shop is confident in the quality of its repairs and committed to customer satisfaction long after the bill is paid.
7. Watch for Transparency
Honest shops don’t mind explaining the details. Ask for a breakdown of the estimate so you understand what you’re paying for. Transparency about parts, labor, and timelines is a strong indicator that the shop respects you as a customer and wants to earn your trust.
8. Be Wary of Rock-Bottom Prices
If an estimate seems too good to be true—it probably is. Extremely low prices can be a red flag for rushed repairs, cheap parts, or inexperienced technicians. In the end, trying to save a few bucks could cost you much more if the job isn’t done right the first time.
9. Trust Your Gut
Finally, trust your instincts. If a shop makes you feel uneasy or dodges your questions, it’s okay to walk away. You deserve to work with professionals who value your safety, your vehicle, and your business.
Aim for value, not just the cheapest price. Price shopping can help you avoid overpaying—but it shouldn’t be your only strategy. Your car is a major investment, and quality repairs are essential for its safety and longevity. Aim to find the best value: a shop that balances fair pricing with high-quality service and peace of mind.
Need Help Choosing? Let Us Make It Easy.
At Sharp Auto Body, we pride ourselves on honest estimates, quality workmanship, and exceptional service. Our technicians are I-CAR certified, we never skimp on parts, and we back all of our repairs with a lifetime warranty. If you have questions or want a no-pressure estimate, give us a call at 847-526-1343—we’re here to help.
